Leadership Mastery: Why the Wrong Decision is Worse than No Decision at All

By Casey Cunningham | June 14, 2024 | Leadership

Mastering Decision-Making in Leadership Challenges...

Click play to listen to this blog post.

Mastering Decision-Making in Leadership Challenges

I've found that the leaders who struggle the most are the ones who are afraid of making decisions. When fear takes hold, decisions get deferred indefinitely, costing companies millions—sometimes even billions—of dollars. Reflecting on my journey, it's clear that decisive actions have been critical to my business's survival and growth. For those of you in leadership roles, the ability to make decisions is not just a skill; it’s an essential aspect of your daily responsibilities.

The Problem: Fear of Decision Making

Many leaders are paralyzed by the stakes of their decisions. Every choice we make can potentially make or break a company, team, project, or investment. This hesitation isn't just a personal struggle; it deeply affects the organizational culture, financial health, and overall growth potential.

I've been in dire situations in business—moments where market conditions threatened to bring us down from millions to virtually zero. The difference between sinking and surviving often hinged on timely, decisive actions. While it’s natural to feel overwhelmed by the pressures of leadership, it’s crucial to see every challenge as an opportunity for greatness.

Embrace Challenges as Opportunities

Every storm brings an opportunity to refine and improve your business. When things go wrong, instead of seeing the problem as a burden, view it as a chance to innovate. There was a time in my career when I lost nearly everything. Faced with the choice to close down, reengineer, or cut costs aggressively, the decisions I made at that crisis point defined my path forward.

Critical moments demand bold decisions. Recognize that problems are huge opportunities. Making quick decisions increases the probability of success. Even if you fail, what's important is that you acted. The lesson learned from failure often provides invaluable insights for future success.

How to Make Effective Decisions

Making effective decisions under high risk is what sets great leaders apart. If you're risk-averse, leadership might not be for you. In leadership, you often have to act on instinct and incomplete information. Here’s how you can navigate these challenges:

  1. Surround Yourself with Trusted Stakeholders: Gather input from people you trust. Listen to their perspectives without interjecting, and then make an informed decision that respects their insights.
  2. Act Swiftly and Confidently: Delaying decisions can erode respect, damage culture, and hurt revenue. Even unpopular decisions, if made swiftly, can be beneficial.
  3. Learn from Every Decision: Reflect on past decisions, both successful and not. For instance, I once invested in a technology venture that failed spectacularly. While the financial loss was significant, the lessons I learned about market readiness and technological pacing were invaluable.

Personal Examples of Decision-Making

I once had a formula that I believed could revolutionize a particular business process. Excited, I invested in developing an app for it back when Palm Pilots were the latest tech. Despite careful planning, the venture failed due to poor pricing strategies and underestimating the rapid advancements in technology. Yet, I have no regrets. This failure taught me the importance of thorough market research and adaptability.

In leadership, you have to embrace the idea that not all decisions will work out. It only takes one good decision to dramatically change your business's trajectory. So, don’t shy away from making decisions out of fear of failure. See each decision as a step forward. If it doesn't work out, learn from it and move on.

Final Thoughts

Always gather the information you need, but trust your instincts as well. You’re in a leadership role because you have those instincts. When in doubt, seek counsel from your trusted team members—they can offer valuable insights that you may overlook.

In conclusion, never second-guess yourself. Make the decision and then celebrate the outcome, whether it’s a success or a failure. Each decision and its result are opportunities to learn and grow. Remember, your team looks to you for direction, so make your decisions confidently and watch your leadership and business thrive.

Have an amazing day, everyone!